Note: Indie Author Magazine, Indie Author Training, and our sister sites maintain a neutral stance on artificial intelligence. In our coverage, we seek to provide an objective, informative take on the technology, and we encourage authors to make decisions about whether to use AI platforms based on their personal values and what’s best for their business.
Since it entered the conversation in early 2023, artificial intelligence has been a controversial topic in publishing. The team behind Vellum, the book formatting platform, has experienced that controversy firsthand over the course of the past few weeks, after they added an optional feature to the platform at the start of November, then removed it two days later after receiving a wave of criticism.
This week, after more authors reached out in person at Author Nation and via email, the three-person team chose to implement the feature again.
The feature, called Automation, allows authors to automatically update the formatting across several titles at once by connecting an AI assistant, such as Claude or ChatGPT, and prompting the AI with the changes they want to make. Examples include updating book details across titles or reformatting a series to look consistent, according to Vellum’s announcement. The feature is fully optional and requires authors to follow several steps in order to set up the tool.
“We've heard for a long time the pain of going back and updating, or wanting to just make that change, but authors are really busy,” said Vellum founder Brad West in an interview last week at Author Nation. “So that is what inspired this feature. It's kind of always what's inspired Vellum. It’s giving authors more time to just do the thing they love best: writing.”

What Happened
The platform originally announced the new feature November 4. But almost immediately, West said, authors opposed to AI responded. “The thing that is interesting for us is when we release a new piece of a new update to our software, as software developers, no news is good news, right? You want to just get it out there, not hear anything—‘great, nothing’s broken,’” he said. “What happened when we released it is we just got … a lot of negative reaction and all very quickly, all in various places, public places. And our gut reaction was, ‘We broke something. We just did something wrong. We overestimated how many people would use this.’”
He continued, “We knew there would be backlash, but … when we just got almost uniformly negative feedback for that first day, we just thought we made a mistake. We missed the mark.”
A day later, on November 5, the company released a second update that removed Automation from the platform. “We know our announcement has upset many authors, and we take your concerns seriously,” the company wrote in the announcement. But that decision frustrated more users—this time, those who had wanted to use the feature.
“That is what inspired this feature. It's kind of always what's inspired Vellum. It’s giving authors more time to just do the thing they love best: writing.”
—Brad West, Vellum founder
The following week, the Vellum team was in Las Vegas to attend the Author Nation conference. West said it offered the team a chance to step back and consider their next move, as well as to hear from the author community directly. Around midday on the conference’s vendor expo day Tuesday, West shared they’d already had several attendees stop by the booth to show their support for Vellum and offer their thoughts on the situation in person.
Those discussions ultimately tipped the team’s decision in the other direction. This past Wednesday, Vellum announced a third update, adding Automation back to the platform.
“We know that this won’t satisfy everyone,” the company wrote in the announcement of the most recent update. “We haven’t forgotten the authors who originally wrote to us, many of whom believe that even the option of Automation is a step too far. We recognize that restoring Automation will upset those authors, just as removing it disappointed others. We don’t take that lightly. But we’ve decided that this is our path forward.”

Where Vellum Stands Now
Following the initial announcement of the Automation feature, West says many authors were concerned AI would be incorporated into the platform. Although that was never the case, West says, the team made that distinction clearer with the re-release of the feature.
“We always thought it was, we've said internally, implicitly opt-in—the fact that it can only work after you connect something. You've got to take five steps to connect it,” West says. “But it wasn't clear to a lot of people. Even people who were in favor of this feature and wanted it came to us with suggestions saying, ‘Why don't you make this optional? Why don't you make this?’” In the latest update, the platform now includes a switch in the settings page that authors must turn on in order to connect an AI platform to Vellum.
West also makes a distinction between assistive and generative AI when talking about the feature. The Automation feature connects to generative AI platforms, but its intention is to serve as an agentic, or assistive, tool; this way, authors can complete repetitive administrative tasks faster and have more time to write. Although it’s hard to prevent authors from using the tools for other things if they wish to—“It's really hard to design it to draw a line and say it can do this and it can't do that,” he says—he compares Automation’s use of AI to that of an advanced spell check.
“We knew there was no way to give a perfect answer that would make everyone happy, but [giving authors] the choice whether to use this or not really felt like the best option we could give.”
—Brad West, Vellum founder
Since the feature’s re-release earlier this week, West says user feedback has been more positive, with many authors celebrating other users having the option to use the tool, even if they don’t intend to use it in their own businesses. Some authors have still been unhappy—he guesses about one in every five emails the team has received has been opposed to the feature. But he also recognizes that it’s impossible to please everyone.
“Twenty percent negative is still a large number. And we're not ignoring it,” he says. “We knew there was no way to give a perfect answer that would make everyone happy, but [giving authors] the choice whether to use this or not really felt like the best option we could give.”
In the platform’s most recent announcement, the team behind Vellum offered an extended return window for users who purchased Vellum since September 1 of this year and are unhappy with the change. They also thanked those who showed support for the platform in the past few weeks. “It was just great to be reminded how many people appreciate what we're working on and just to support us,” West says.
For those interested in learning about future updates to Vellum, West encourages authors to sign up for the platform’s mailing list at https://vellum.pub. Users can also share their thoughts and suggestions for future updates through the contact form on the website. “Right now we're focusing on stabilizing this feature and probably getting some sleep and spending some time with our families,” West says. “But yeah, we are always looking to see what features can help our users, and we'll continue doing that.”
